When it comes to wireless earbuds, Apple has set the bar high with its iconic AirPods lineup. But if you’re shopping for a pair and comfort is your top priority, you’re probably stuck deciding between two popular choices: AirPods 2 and AirPods Pro.
At first glance, they might look somewhat similar—sleek, white, minimalist—but when it comes to comfort, they offer two very different experiences. So, which one is more comfortable and why? Let’s dive into the details and compare AirPods 2 and AirPods Pro side by side.
A Quick Overview of the Contenders
Before we focus on comfort specifically, it helps to understand the basic differences between these two models:
AirPods 2 (2nd Generation):
-
Released in 2019
-
Universal “one-size-fits-most” hard plastic design
-
No noise cancellation
-
Lighter and slightly smaller
-
Lower price point
AirPods Pro:
-
First released in 2019, updated in 2022 (2nd Gen)
-
In-ear design with soft silicone ear tips in multiple sizes
-
Active Noise Cancellation (ANC) and Transparency Mode
-
Slightly heavier due to added features
-
Higher price point
Now let’s talk comfort—because how your earbuds feel during a long commute, a workout, or a movie marathon makes a big difference.
What Does “Comfort” Really Mean for Earbuds?
Before picking a side, we should define what makes earbuds comfortable:
-
Fit – Do they stay in your ears securely without pressure or pain?
-
Weight – Lighter buds tend to feel more “invisible” in the ear.
-
Material – Hard plastic vs soft silicone changes how it feels inside your ear.
-
Ear Sensitivity – Everyone’s ear shape is different, and comfort can be subjective.
-
Duration – How do they feel after 30 minutes vs 3 hours?
Now, let’s see how the AirPods Pro and AirPods 2 measure up in each of these areas.
Fit and Stability
AirPods 2:
The AirPods 2 follow Apple’s classic “universal fit” design. They rest just outside the ear canal and don’t create a seal. Some people love how they “just sit there” without pressure. However, others find that they fall out easily, especially during exercise or movement.
They’re great for casual use or for people who dislike anything inside their ears. But if your ears are on the smaller or larger side, they might feel loose or even uncomfortable.
AirPods Pro:
The AirPods Pro take a different approach: they come with three sizes of soft silicone ear tips, allowing you to find a more personalized fit. Once you find the right size, they create a gentle seal inside the ear canal, which helps them stay put better—even during workouts.
For many users, the ability to customize the fit makes the AirPods Pro feel more secure and comfortable.
Winner: AirPods Pro – because of the customizable fit.
Weight and Feel
AirPods 2:
These are lighter (about 4g per earbud), and some users say they “forget they’re wearing them” after a while. The open design means there’s less pressure, which is good for people who don’t like the sensation of earbuds “digging” into their ears.
AirPods Pro:
Although slightly heavier (about 5.4g per bud), the AirPods Pro distribute the weight well. Once seated correctly, they don’t feel heavy or burdensome. The silicone tips also provide a softer touch compared to hard plastic.
That said, people sensitive to “in-ear” designs might feel the seal or pressure, especially during extended use.
Tie – depends on personal preference for in-ear vs. resting-on-ear fit.
Material and Sensory Feel
AirPods 2:
Made entirely of smooth hard plastic, the AirPods 2 are non-intrusive if they fit your ears well. However, for some people, the lack of flexibility makes them uncomfortable over time.
If you’ve ever had a sore spot after wearing your AirPods too long, you’re not alone. These earbuds either “click” with your ears or they don’t—there’s not much room for adjustment.
AirPods Pro:
The AirPods Pro feature soft, flexible silicone tips, which conform better to your ear shape. This not only improves noise isolation but also reduces discomfort caused by rigid materials. Plus, the Ear Tip Fit Test in your iPhone helps you find the best fit.
For people with sensitive ears, the silicone can be a game changer. But a small percentage of users report irritation or discomfort after long use—especially if the tips aren’t cleaned regularly.
Winner: AirPods Pro – more adaptable material, better pressure distribution.
Noise Cancellation vs. Open-Air Feel
This may not seem directly related to comfort—but it is!
AirPods 2:
With their open design, AirPods 2 allow ambient noise to flow freely. This means:
-
Less ear pressure
-
No “plugged” feeling
-
Easier to stay aware of your surroundings
This can be more mentally comfortable for people who don’t like being isolated from the world, especially when walking, biking, or working in a shared space.
AirPods Pro:
The AirPods Pro offer Active Noise Cancellation, which blocks out background noise and gives a peaceful listening experience. They also include Transparency Mode, which lets in ambient sound without taking out the buds—great for walking outside or chatting briefly.
However, the noise isolation can feel strange to some users at first, and might take a little getting used to.
Winner: Subjective – choose based on whether you like full isolation or ambient awareness.
Long Listening Sessions: Who Wins for All-Day Wear?
AirPods 2:
If they fit your ears well, AirPods 2 can feel weightless. Their design allows airflow, which helps prevent that “sweaty ear” feeling. However, the hard plastic can cause pressure points during extended wear.
Some users report ear fatigue or aching after a few hours—especially if the fit isn’t perfect.
AirPods Pro:
The AirPods Pro, thanks to their customizable silicone tips and ergonomic design, can be worn comfortably for longer periods—if the fit is right. They provide a more “locked-in” feeling, which is great for long flights, focus sessions, or noisy environments.
However, extended wear might cause mild pressure for some users, especially if they’ve never used in-ear headphones before.
Winner: AirPods Pro – thanks to their adaptability and soft-touch design.
Scientific & User Feedback: What Do Reviews Say?
What do experts and users generally say?
-
AirPods Pro are often rated higher for comfort in professional reviews, mainly due to the silicone tips and custom fit.
-
AirPods 2 are loved for their simplicity and weightlessness—but only if they match your ear shape well.
Here’s a snapshot of real user experiences:
-
“I couldn’t keep the AirPods 2 in my ears. They just fell out during workouts. The Pro stays in place and feels more natural.”
-
“I can wear my AirPods 2 all day at work with no issues. The Pro gave me a weird pressure after a couple of hours.”
-
“The Pro’s noise cancellation is not just great for sound—it’s relaxing. I love the quiet.”
Overall consensus: AirPods Pro come out ahead for the majority of users in comfort—especially over long durations.
Final Verdict: Which AirPods Are More Comfortable?
When comparing AirPods 2 vs. AirPods Pro, it’s clear that comfort is subjective. That said, if we weigh the key factors—fit, material, long-term use, and adaptability—the AirPods Pro take the win for most people.
Choose AirPods Pro if you:
-
Want a customizable fit with silicone tips
-
Prefer secure earbuds for workouts or movement
-
Like active noise cancellation
-
Use your earbuds for long periods
Choose AirPods 2 if you:
-
Dislike the feeling of earbuds inside your ear canal
-
Want ultra-light earbuds with minimal pressure
-
Have ears that perfectly match Apple’s “universal” fit
-
Prefer open-ear awareness over full isolation
Final Tips Before Buying
-
Try before you buy, if possible—comfort is personal!
-
Use the Ear Tip Fit Test on AirPods Pro to get the best seal and sound.
-
Consider foam ear tips for AirPods Pro if silicone isn’t working for you.
-
If budget is a concern, the AirPods 2 still offer solid performance and comfort—for the right ears.
Whichever you choose, Apple’s AirPods lineup offers premium sound, sleek design, and the kind of wireless experience that makes everyday listening a breeze.
